Skip to main content

Author: admin

What’s in a name?

Being mistaken for someone else can be a right laugh sometimes. I once turned up to an event in Buxton and introduced myself as ‘Phil Hayes’, which is my name, and several people giggled. This was slightly confusing, but I put it down to the famous Derbyshire sense of humour. Only later did I find out why my name was so amusing to them. And so will you, if you read to the end of this.

There is a more serious side though. At Hayes Collins Media, we sometimes receive emails for a furniture manufacturer. We don’t make sofas, we train people to be interviewed on them. On TV. Collins and Hayes do make sofas, and they’re lucky that we reply to their confused customers and point them in the right direction. If we didn’t, then a minor problem could escalate into a bigger argument, if a disgruntled furniture shopper felt like they were being ignored.

In a broadcast interview, you don’t want to be called by the wrong name, but do you want to correct it? Does saying “It’s Alex, actually.” make you look like a pedant to the audience? Or should you just let it slide? Well, maybe you should. Unless it’s the name of your organisation, project or product that’s being misnamed. Because that’s one of the reasons that you’re there – to persuade people and to build your brand. So find a form of words that allows you to correct the reporter with good grace, like “Here at the Health and Safety Executive we know that…”. This is good practice anyway, even if they’ve got your name right, as it reinforces who you are, and why the audience should listen to you.

So those are two examples of innocent mistakes. What about mischief?

On social media, particularly Twitter, there’s a long tradition of parody accounts. These are often very funny and say what we’re all thinking about the inner thought processes of a public figure who’s on the ropes. Sometimes though, people don’t realise they are parodies and even though it’s common to see the word ‘PARODY’ in the description, it’s not always there. Here are two examples I’ve recently encountered in which journalists and members of the public either failed to notice parodic content, or chose to ignore it for a story.

Firstly, Wetherspoons got into trouble in 2018, over claims that it had banned staff from wearing remembrance poppies. This didn’t exactly sound right, given Wetherspoons’ general politics and sure enough, as The Guardian reported it came from a spoof account, not the official Wetherspoons Twitter account. It didn’t help that the spoof account (@Wetherspoon_UK) sounds more real than the genuine account (@jdwtweet), so make sure your social media names make sense to you, monitor what’s said about you (including parody accounts and misspellings of your brand) and respond to set the record straight.

Sometimes it’s not your brand, but the brand that offered the same service before you. Here in the West Midlands, many of our local buses are run by National Express, who use the Twitter handle @nxwestmidlands. For many years before National Express, services were run by Travel West Midlands and the twitter handle @travelwm gets you to a parody account, which does its best to spread chaos. Like a local transport embodiment of Anansi the spider god. Who would also have a web presence.

To be serious for a moment, @nxwestmidlands does mention in its description box that they are the only Twitter account for National Express, but for an audience with a long memory (my mother used to call the buses WMPTE, which they haven’t been for decades) that may not be enough. I’m guessing the National Express West Midlands social media team spend a lot of time monitoring and responding to stop customer relations going off the rails. Or should that be roads?

And for those of you wondering why I was such a hit in Buxton, here’s a link to the Health and Safety Laboratory where one of the scientists is a man with grey hair in a white lab coat called Phil Hayes. You can also hear me interviewing him on this podcast for the Health and Safety Executive because, as a media trainer, it’s good to ask the questions for real as well as just in the training room.

Slogans are not speech

Yes, your communications must be aligned. You must say the same thing on social media as on TV and radio news. Your switchboard must have access to the same core script that you’re using for broadcast. Your paid publicity (posters and adverts) must be in sync with your PR (interviews and events). But you shouldn’t speak in slogans. Because slogans are not speech. What looks okay on the front of a leaflet will make you sound like a robot.

If you’ve travelled by train recently, you’ll have heard the slogan “see it, say it, sorted” over the loudspeakers. It’s a catchy phrase, but it doesn’t sound quite human to me. Until today, when a staff member on a Chiltern lines train said: “If you see anything that doesn’t look right, tell us. See it, say it and we’ll sort it.” That little adaptation of the last phrase was just enough to make the staff member sound like a real person and give the message real impact, while still remaining close enough to the original slogan.

I think it’s important to give people the confidence to be themselves and get messages across in a way that fits their own style. We need to trust our teams to flex the delivery, while we’re confident that the message is still aligned with what we want.

Often in the media training room, we’ll be really pleased when the same scenario produces different styles of interviews from one delegate to another. We’re not looking to produce a row of robots, all saying the same thing in the same way. You need to put yourself into the story. Be confident enough to be the real you.

But there’s a limit. When writing a previous blog post about Boeing, I realised I needed to research how to spell Dennis Muilenburg’s name – partly because I’d heard it on the radio and partly because it’s a name where it would be possible to get both parts of it wrong.

I went online and found this article. When I got to the bit about impact, the apology was linked to how it felt very personal to Mr Muilenburg. This felt to me like the right level of detail – a demonstration of empathy, which doesn’t slip into feeling sorry for himself. Many of us can remember the way that Tony Hayward of BP apologised for the Deepwater Horizon oil spill in the Gulf of Mexico and then immediately ruined that apology by saying: “There’s no one who wants this over more than I do. I’d like my life back.”

Of course, it’s good to show that you are determined to fix the problems and that you are invested in the process. But this smacked of self pity. Sure enough, when he appeared before a Congressional Committee weeks later, Tony Hayward was on the receiving end of those words, both from the politicians who repeated them back to him when holding him to account, and from Channel 4 News’ Sarah Smith, whose package included that CNN clip I’ve linked to above.

Because words do have power and effect. So, choose them carefully and authentically. Be you. You on a good day.

Wusses Welcome

Some people love being in front of the camera. But as a media trainer of some twenty years standing, I’d estimate ‘some’ being about 5% of the population. The rest of us are bloody terrified.

There’s nothing like a camera or a microphone to reduce even the most confident and experienced CEO, army officer or top surgeon to a wobbling jelly of insecurity, and many will choose to cope with this fear by avoiding media interviews like the proverbial plague.

It won’t come as a blinding revelation to anyone that it’s not just the cocky loudmouths of this world who’ve got something to say, so unless we want to exclude the views of 95% of the population, we need to find ways of getting over the fear, so in an attempt to distill a full day’s training course into a single blog post, here’s what we’ve found has helped:

Fear is normal. Your primitive instincts will kick in whenever they sense danger, and anything unknown or unpredictable falls into that category. That adrenalin rush is terribly useful if you need to run away from a saber-toothed tiger – not so much if you need to feel calm and composed in front of the camera. But recognising what’s going on is half the battle.

You’ve earned your right to be there. Yes you. They’re not asking you out of charity. You have something to say and people want to hear it. 

We want you to be a human being, not a robot. If you’re too slick and sound rehearsed, no-one’s going to trust you. And trust is the absolute most basic currency of the relationship between you and your audience.

Talking of which, that’s what it’s all about. Not you and the journalist, you and the audience, so focus on what they need to hear, not what you want to say. Many people find it useful to picture someone they’re trying to influence and pitch it at their level.

Don’t just wing it. In the words of everyone’s favourite cliché, fail to prepare and prepare to fail. There’s no way your panicked brain will be able to construct a great answer on the hoof, so be clear about your three most important messages.

Speak like a real person not a walking, talking annual report. As Churchill said, short words are better, and he was no slouch on the inspiring front. Business-speak won’t impress people, it’ll just put them to sleep.

Know your enemies. Where are you vulnerable? Who’s having a pop at you and how are you going to deal with that without getting defensive? You don’t want to spend the whole of the interview in their territory so have something good ready to pull the interview back on track.

Say it out loud. Get a colleague to throw a few questions at you and practise out loud – not so that you learn your answers verbatim but so the sense of your key messages is cemented in your brain.

Most journalists don’t wake up every morning wondering whose reputation they can destroy that day. It’s in their interest for you to give a good performance so don’t treat them as the enemy but as a way through to your audience.

Your biggest danger is not saying the wrong thing, it’s being so bland that you end up with no-one listening. Use examples to make your point real and relevant so that what you want to say and what the audience ends up hearing are as close as they can possibly be.

On Words and Deeds

I was struck this week during two very different media training courses by the connection between communication and actions. Firstly I was in the north of England, working with a social care organisation on a story around historic abuse. As the organisation’s chief executive spoke about her desire to make amends and to help the victims I became aware that I believed in her sincerity. I asked myself why.

I realised that her words were not just slogans, designed to protect reputation, but came from a real need to do whatever possible to ease the pain of people they should have been helping. As someone who had worked in social care for many years, her empathy with those affected was helping her to find the right words and get them across in the right way.

Clearly that’s a marginal case and we can’t all have decades of experience in the caring professions. But I think there’s a lesson for us all there. Talk about what you know. Then, when you talk about the people you met yesterday, either colleagues, customers or another group altogether, it will be real to you. And you can make it real for the audience. If you feel proud of doing a good job and helping someone, we will see that pride in your face and hear it in your voice. Similarly, if you’re exciting by a new project because you’ve been out and about to see the results for yourself, we can share in that emotion. Make it real for us.

The second training course was in London and was Crisis-focussed. A delegate asked me what communications techniques can be used when a family is criticising you for a poor response. I told that delegate that it shouldn’t be about just communications but also action. Meet the family. Find out what their concerns are. They may still criticise you, which they’re free to do. They may say the meeting wasn’t as useful as they hoped, but you will have met them. Not so you can say “I’ve met them”, but so that you have a greater understanding of each other’s perspective.

Often we think that there’s a magic technique which will get us out of trouble with one bound. In reality, it’s more about what we do as part of our business. Good actions lead to good communications, so I’d like to thank those two delegates, both north and south, for giving me an insight into that.

Choosing the Right Words

The crash of two Boeing 737 Max aeroplanes, in Indonesia and then in Ethiopia, is clearly a major story and a crisis for the aircraft manufacturer. So, they were careful to consider the right time to make a public statement. Sadly, the choice of words that Beoing’s CEO Dennis Muilenburg used in his first TV interview were not so carefully chosen.

At the end of May, I was listening to Radio 4’s 0530 News Briefing when I first heard a clip from the TV interview and the words he used certainly woke me up. He apologised, which is good, but he apologised “for the impact”. A very poor choice of words, which made me think in visceral detail of the crashes. If those words had that effect on me, who is an interested bystander, I can only imagine how distressing they would be to people more closely connected to the crashes.

Words have power and should be chosen carefully, to make sure the effect they have is the effect you want them to have.

This is why, in media training, we talk about planning your key messages ahead of time. If your answers are interesting – and after one of our courses they will be – a journalist will often ask a follow-up question. This is why we test the messages ahead of time. If the example you’ve given triggers a follow up that takes you in a direction you don’t like, then that’s an example that needs to be ditched in favour of something better.

You can’t expect to do this on the hoof. We use realistic camera equipment and make the mock interviews on our courses feel very real. Afterwards delegates tell us that the adrenaline was pumping. In that environment, construction of an answer is nigh on impossible, so it’s much better to recall what you planned to say, rather than build it in front of the reporter. It’ll still be authentic, because it’s still what you decided to say. You just made the decision a few minutes ago, when you could healthcheck it with the help of your comms team (because you’re not on your own when you agree to an interview).

Resist the ‘magic bullet’ answer that pops into your head on the hoof. You won’t have healthchecked the likely follow up questions and, if you’re anything like me, you’ll be so pleased with yourself for coming up with something under pressure (anything!) that you won’t properly question whether it’s any good. And when you hear the terrible follow up question, only then will you know it wasn’t.

Why Hillary Clinton became a ‘pant suit aficionado’

When Hillary Clinton described herself as a ‘pant suit aficionado’ it was a wry acknowledgement that – even at 69 – what women wear is scrutinised just as much as what they say.

As a media trainer, advising women on what to wear (and more often what not to wear) for TV interviews is a fraught and dangerous area.  I remember the (very senior) executive who turned up for training in an eye popping combination of head to toe leopard print and sky-high heels. And much as I admired the sheer chutzpah of someone who had eschewed the navy suit for an ensemble best described as 70s era Bet Lynch, it was a look unlikely to support the very serious messages she needed to get across.

Whilst feminist-me wants to shriek ‘ladies, wear what the hell you like – we fought for the right for you to wear animal print on Newsnight’, the practical me knows that it’s a shortcut to the outfit becoming the story. Witness the Washington Post’s verdict on Mrs Clinton having the audacity to wear a v-neck:

“There wasn’t an unseemly amount of cleavage showing, but there it was. Undeniable.”

So after we’ve given a heavy sigh, let’s button up, because at the end of the day you want the audience to listen to what you’re saying, not be distracted by what you’re wearing. I remember once being mesmerised by an interview in which the woman’s dangly earrings swung to and fro like a turbo-charged executive desk toy every time she moved her head.

I remember the earrings but I can’t recall a word she said.